The pulp and paper industry, traditionally associated with significant waste generation, is now exploring innovative avenues to repurpose its byproducts.
One such promising application is the conversion of paper mill waste into biofuels, notably renewable diesel and sustainable aviation fuel (SAF). This article delves into the feasibility, capital and operational expenditures, and cost-effectiveness of this transformation.
Paper Mill Waste as a Biofuel Feedstock
Paper mills produce various waste streams, including:
- Black Liquor: A byproduct of the kraft process, rich in lignin and organic compounds.
- Sludge: Comprising cellulose fibers, ash, and microbial biomass from wastewater treatment.
- Wood Residues: Unutilized lignocellulosic materials like bark and wood chips.
These waste materials are abundant in organic content, making them suitable candidates for biofuel production through processes such as gasification, pyrolysis, and fermentation.
Conversion Pathways to Biofuels
The transformation of paper mill waste into biofuels involves several technological pathways:
- Gasification followed by Fischer-Tropsch Synthesis: Converts organic waste into syngas, which is then processed into liquid fuels like renewable diesel and SAF.
- Anaerobic Digestion: Breaks down organic sludge to produce biogas, which can be upgraded to biomethane.
- Pyrolysis: Thermally decomposes biomass to yield bio-oil, which can be refined into renewable diesel.
- Fermentation: Processes cellulose-rich waste into bioethanol, a potential aviation fuel component.
Economic Analysis: Capital and Operating Expenditures
Capital Expenditure (CapEx)
Establishing a biorefinery to process paper mill waste into SAF involves significant investment. A study on SAF production from forest residues estimates a total capital investment of approximately $422 million for a facility processing 960 metric tonnes per day, yielding 90 metric tonnes of SAF daily.
Operating Expenditure (OpEx)
The annual operating cost for such a facility is around $79 million. Key cost components include:
- Feedstock Procurement: Approximately 16% of OpEx.
- Facility Operations: Around 69%, encompassing labour, maintenance, and utilities.
- Utilities: About 8%, primarily for high-pressure steam used in various processing stages.
These figures highlight the substantial operational costs associated with biofuel production from lignocellulosic waste.
Cost per Metric Tonne and Litre
The production cost of SAF from forest residues is estimated at approximately $1.87 per kilogram, considering revenue from byproducts like green diesel and electricity. This translates to about $1,870 per metric tonne. Assuming a density similar to conventional jet fuel (0.8 kg/L), the cost per litre is roughly $1.50
In comparison, the production cost of biodiesel from waste cooking oil ranges between $750 and $1,048 per metric tonne, depending on the processing method employed.
Market Viability and Challenges
While the technological feasibility of converting paper mill waste into biofuels is established, economic viability remains a challenge. SAF currently costs two to three times more than conventional jet fuel, posing a significant barrier to widespread adoption. Government mandates, such as the UK’s requirement for airlines to use a minimum of 2% SAF, are driving demand. However, the high production costs necessitate substantial investments and policy support to achieve scalability and cost reductions.
The conversion of paper mill waste into renewable diesel and SAF presents a sustainable avenue for waste value realisation and greenhouse gas emission reduction. Despite the promising environmental benefits, the high capital and operating expenditures, coupled with current market dynamics, pose economic challenges. Strategic investments, technological advancements, and supportive policies are crucial to enhancing the cost-effectiveness and scalability of this biofuel production pathway.
Sources
Royal Society of Chemistry J. P. Ahire, R. Bergman, T. Runge, S. H. Mousavi-Avval, D. Bhattacharyya, T. Brown and J. Wang
National Library of Medicin Techno-Economic Evaluation of Biodiesel Production from Waste Cooking Oil—A Case Study of Hong Kong Sanjib Kumar Karmee, Raffel Dharma Patria, Carol Sze Ki Lin,
The post Transforming Paper Mill Waste into Renewable Diesel and Sustainable Aviation Fuel: A Techno-Economic Perspective first appeared on Haush.